Dear Puranjana dasa, you should not be shy to publish my comment even if it does not support your cause. Your Madhu Pandit lacks understanding of Srila Prabhupada teaching. What has christianity got to do with vaishnavism. More specifically what has our guru parampara got to do with Jesus Christ taking the sins of others.
Taking shelter of a pure devotee/s, yes. But don't disguise it as means to propagate the bogus ritvikism.
Ok so who is taking the sins in your proposal? You cannot simply say we are wrong, that called neti neti, you are discounting the opponnent. That neti neti style is not allowed in Vedic debates, you also have to give the actual conclusion. You have not told us who is accepting the sins? So we do have a conclusion, you have none? You are simply saying that a pure devotee like Jesus cannot absorb sins today, but Srila Prabhupada says he still is? And you have not told us who is going to replace someone like Jesus either? You have to do better than neti neti. ys pd
Thanks Wyatt but we have no idea what your point is? Are you saying we should take shelter of a pure devotee, or not? ys pd
ReplyDeleteDear Puranjana dasa, you should not be shy to publish my comment
ReplyDeleteeven if it does not support your cause. Your Madhu Pandit lacks
understanding of Srila Prabhupada teaching. What has christianity
got to do with vaishnavism. More specifically what has our
guru parampara got to do with Jesus Christ taking the sins of
others.
Taking shelter of a pure devotee/s, yes. But don't disguise it as means to propagate the bogus ritvikism.
Hare Krsna.
Ok so who is taking the sins in your proposal? You cannot simply say we are wrong, that called neti neti, you are discounting the opponnent. That neti neti style is not allowed in Vedic debates, you also have to give the actual conclusion. You have not told us who is accepting the sins? So we do have a conclusion, you have none? You are simply saying that a pure devotee like Jesus cannot absorb sins today, but Srila Prabhupada says he still is? And you have not told us who is going to replace someone like Jesus either? You have to do better than neti neti. ys pd
ReplyDelete