Monday, February 9, 2026

ISKCON Constitution: Centralization and bureaucracy: GOVINDA DASI 02 09 26


GOVINDA DASI

DEFINITELY LONG-WINDED BUT ALSO WORTH A QUICK READ:
The NEW ISKCON “CONSTITUTION” inaugurated on Feb. 4,2026, in Mayapur
_______________________________________

Subject: Gemini AI analysis of Iskcon’s constitution

The Architecture of Ecclesiastical Hegemony: A Comprehensive Analysis of the ISKCON Constitution and the Crisis of Institutional Legitimacy.

The formal inauguration of the International Society for Krishna Consciousness (ISKCON) Constitution on February 4, 2026, in Śrīdhāma Māyāpur, ostensibly marked the culmination of a decades-long effort to codify the administrative and theological framework of a movement that has transitioned from a charismatic startup to a global religious institution. This document, offered ceremonially by the Governing Body Commission (GBC) Chairman to the murti of the Founder-Ācārya, A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupāda, seeks to present a unified and enduring framework for governance that aligns with both scriptural mandates and modern legal requirements. 

However, a rigorous structural and comparative analysis reveals that this constitution fundamentally lacks the essential features of modern constitutionalism, such as an enforceable bill of rights and a clear separation of powers, while institutionalizing a degree of centralization that contradicts the explicit, recorded instructions of the founder. The resulting document functions less as a charter for the protection of its constituents and more as a mechanism for the consolidation of power within the GBC, creating significant risk for temple administrators and individual devotees alike.

Structural Deficiencies and the Omission of Fundamental Constitutional Safeguards:

In the landscape of modern political and organizational theory, a constitution is defined not merely by its existence but by its capacity to limit power and protect the governed through established precedents. The ISKCON Constitution, particularly as evidenced through Draft 4 and the 2026 finalized text, omits several basic features that are considered central to the legitimacy of any constitutional order. The most significant omission is the lack of an independent judiciary or any mechanism for judicial review. 

In states like India, the "basic structure" doctrine ensures that even a sovereign parliament cannot alter the core features of the constitution, a principle upheld by the Supreme Court to prevent majoritarian tyranny. Within ISKCON, however, the GBC remains the "ultimate managing authority," acting simultaneously as the legislative body that creates the law and the final court of appeal that interprets it. This collapse of functions into a single body removes the "checks and balances" necessary to prevent the misuse of power.

Furthermore, the document is notably silent on the specific legal rights of the individual devotee, a vacuum that stands in stark contrast to the robust Bill of Rights found in almost all democratic constitutions. While the constitution mentions "protecting the rights of individuals" as a purpose, it fails to define those rights or provide a mechanism for their enforcement. 

PADA: Yeah Rocana was saying that the GBC guru system of "voting in acharyas" is a valid and great idea, but he said there is no good system to enforce the GBC "guru rules" -- when their fall down or their acharyas break the rules. Duh. An acharya is not subordinate to a committee of conditioned souls. But yeah, there is no mechanism to enforce containing wayward acharyas, nor any protections for the citizens.

There is no stated right to due process, no guarantee of a fair hearing before an impartial body, and no right to compensation for mistreatment by leadership. Instead, the document focuses on the "rights" of the organization and the GBC’s authority to maintain "standards". This structural imbalance ensures that the individual remains legally "powerless" within the movement’s hierarchical justice system.

Constitutional Feature | Standard Democratic Model (e.g., India / USA) | ISKCON 2026 Constitutional Framework |

Separation of Powers | Legislative, Executive, and Judicial branches are distinct and independent. | GBC holds ultimate authority over all three functions; no independent judiciary. 

Individual Rights | Enforceable Bill of Rights protecting citizens from the state. 

Focus on organizational and GBC rights; individual rights are undefined. 

Judicial Review | Courts can strike down unconstitutional laws or executive actions. 

No body exists to nullify a GBC resolution; the GBC is the final arbiter. 

Electoral Mandate | Regular, transparent elections by the citizenry establish legitimacy. 

GBC is largely self-appointing; the 1970 electoral mandate is excluded. 

Due Process | Strict procedures for prosecution and defense must be followed. 

Procedures for the "powerless" are often summary; "cronyism" affects enforcement. 

The omission of these features creates a document that is fundamentally "pro-GBC" in its bias. By framing the GBC as the "instrument for the execution of the Will of His Divine Grace," the constitution elevates an administrative body to a status of quasi-infallibility, where dissent is often interpreted not as a legal or managerial disagreement, but as a theological "offense".

PADA: Quasi infallible, heh heh heh. 

This theological grounding, while perhaps inspirational to followers, serves to shield the GBC from the types of scrutiny that are standard in non-profit and religious organizations globally.

Inherent Contradictions: Theology vs. Bureaucracy

A critical examination of the ISKCON Constitution reveals deep-seated contradictions between its stated spiritual aspirations and its operational mechanisms. The most prominent contradiction lies in the tension between the desire to be "less legalistic" and the reliance on a dense, hierarchical corpus known as "ISKCON Law". 

PADA: Yeah, when someone was asking his GBC guru about some of the "laws," the guru did not even know which ISKCON law was being discussed. He said he has not read all of the laws, and was not aware of many of them. 

While the constitution’s preamble and dedication use the language of "love and trust," the actual governing statutes establish what management theorists call a "Machine of Bureaucracy". In such a system, the standardization of work processes and the strict adherence to central rules become more important than the individual spiritual development of the members. This contradiction is particularly evident in how the society handles "sensitive matters" like child protection and the "ritvik" controversy; rather than transparent legal processes, these are addressed through appendices that reinforce GBC policy under the guise of "founder's instructions".

Another significant contradiction exists between the claim that ISKCON temples are "financially independent" and the reality of "ecclesiastical management" by the GBC. A temple cannot be truly independent if a centralized body has the authority to appoint and remove its administrators, set its spiritual and managerial standards, and require significant financial contributions to a global fund. 

This "illusion of autonomy" creates a situation where temple administrators bear all the financial and legal risks of their local operations, while the GBC maintains the power to intervene and exert control without corresponding financial responsibility. This structural contradiction leads to frequent friction between local interests and central mandates, as seen in the protracted legal battle over the Bengaluru temple, where the GBC sought to exert ownership over a temple that claimed independent legal identity.

Level of Governance | Stated Purpose (Constitutional Rhetoric) | Operational Reality (Ecclesiastical Practice) 

 Global GBC | To preserve the founder’s teachings and maintain unity. 

Acts as a centralized bureaucracy with unchecked legislative and judicial power. 

Zonal Secretary | To supervise and assist local centers "nicely". 

Exercises absolute authority over temple presidents and local personnel. 

Temple President | To act with "local initiative" and financial independence. 

Functions as an "at-will" manager subject to summary removal by the GBC. 

Individual Devotee | To progress spiritually in an environment of safety and respect. 

Remains legally "powerless" with no enforceable rights or grievance redressal. 

These contradictions are easily overlooked by trusting followers because they are often presented through a "Founder-Ācārya" filter. By quoting Śrīla Prabhupāda extensively — more than fifty percent of the text consists of such quotes — the GBC leverages his charismatic authority to justify a bureaucratic system that he, in fact, warned against. 

This "traditionalist bias" creates a theological shield; to question the constitution is framed as questioning the founder himself, even when the document’s administrative specifics deviate from his recorded letters and legal mandates.

The Devotional Perspective: Decentralization and the "Love and Trust" Mandate
From a devotional and management perspective, the 2026 Constitution must be measured against the explicit instructions of Śrīla Prabhupāda regarding the discouragement of centralization. 

In a seminal 1972 letter to Karandhara, Prabhupāda wrote, "Forget this centralizing and bureaucracy... Once there is bureaucracy the whole thing will be spoiled". He envisioned a movement where "each temple must remain independent and self-sufficient" and where management was handled locally by local men. The 2026 Constitution, however, formalizes a trajectory of increasing centralization that began in the early 1970s and was explicitly rebuked by the founder at the time.

The most critical management instruction overlooked by the 2026 Constitution is the 1970 "Direction of Management" (DOM). This legal document, signed by Prabhupāda, established a system of "checks and balances" where GBC members were to be elected by Temple Presidents for three-year terms. The GBC’s failure to implement these elections represents a fundamental deviation from the founder’s management vision. Instead of the GBC serving as the "servants of the Temple Presidents," the 2026 Constitution cements their position as a self-appointing, permanent oligarchy. 

This lack of an electoral mandate is not a minor detail but a theological failure (guru-aparādha), as it ignores the specific "TOPMOST URGENCY" instructions given by the founder to establish a representative governance structure.

Management Principle | Śrīla Prabhupāda’s Instruction | 2026 Constitutional Implementation |

Centralization | "Do not centralize anything... centralization is nonsense proposals". | Establishes global ministries and mandatory centralized standards for all local centers. |

GBC Election | GBC to be elected by Temple Presidents for 3-year terms. 

GBC is self-appointing; electoral mandate is absent from the 2026 text. 

Bureaucracy | "Krishna Consciousness is for training men to be independently thoughtful... not for making bureaucracy". | Creates a complex, multi-layered "Machine Bureaucracy" with limited accountability. 

Temple Autonomy | TPs are responsible; GBC is to see that things go "nicely," not exert absolute authority. 

Zonal Secretaries exercise "absolute authority" over local management and finances. 

The 2026 "3/35 Vision" in North America serves as a contemporary example of this tension. While it uses the rhetoric of "empowered devotees" and "strong communities," the structural mechanism—the "Growth Acceleration Teams" (GATs)—functions as a service office that reinforces zonal unity under the GBC’s direction. 

In a truly decentralized model, these support structures would be initiated and controlled by the local temples they serve; under the 2026 Constitution, they are top-down initiatives designed to ensure that the "front-line leaders" (Temple Presidents) remain focused on the central mission while administrative control is consolidated at the zonal level. This management shift from "local initiative" to "zonal compliance" represents a profound departure from the organic growth model of the movement's early years.

Impact on Temple Administrators: Support vs. Ecclesiastical Control
For temple administrators, the 2026 Constitution presents a dual reality of nominal support and absolute ecclesiastical oversight. According to the GBC’s "Governance Structure" document, Temple Presidents are encouraged to act with "local initiative," yet they are simultaneously defined as "working under the supervision of their assigned GBC zonal secretary". 

This creates a "managerial sandwich" where the TP must satisfy the spiritual and financial demands of a global hierarchy while maintaining the daily operations of a financially independent local center.

The support available to these administrators primarily comes through Zonal Support Offices and specialized Ministries (e.g., Deity Worship, Education). However, this "support" often takes the form of additional regulations and certification requirements. For example, the 2025 resolution on Deity Worship mandates that all courses must be approved by the Deity Worship Ministry and taught only by authorized devotees. 

While intended to maintain standards, such centralization strips the local Temple President of the authority to train and empower their own priests based on local needs and talent, forcing them to rely on a central bureaucracy for basic temple functions.

Category of Support | Nominal Resource | Actual Power Dynamic |

Managerial Guidance | Zonal Secretaries. | Exercise the power to remove the TP if "standards" are not met. |

Spiritual Standards | GBC Ministries (Education, Deity Worship). | Centralized control over local curriculum and liturgical practices. |

Conflict Resolution | ISKCONResolve (Mediation). | Voluntary; a powerful leader can refuse to participate, leaving the TP unsupported. |

Financial Security | "Financial Independence". | Local centers bear all risk; "cronyism" often dictates which projects receive central backing. |

The most precarious aspect of the Temple President's position under the new constitution is the removal process. While the 1970 DOM mandated that a Temple President could only be removed with the "support by the local Temple members," the current legal framework allows for removal or censure by the GBC and its Zonal Secretaries for "misconduct" or "spiritual discrepancy". 

This lack of local "veto power" over leadership changes means that Temple Presidents are functionally accountable only to the GBC hierarchy, not to the community they serve. This shift facilitates a culture of "cronyism," where loyalty to the GBC is more vital for administrative survival than effective community leadership.

The Individual Devotee Perspective: Inaction, Cronyism, and the Crisis of Justice
From the perspective of an individual devotee—the group categorized as the "powerless" in critical analyses of ISKCON Law—the 2026 Constitution and its associated legal framework fail to provide meaningful protection against mistreatment. The document lacks the "language of justice". 

Words like "fair," "impartial," and "equal" appear in ISKCON Law primarily to describe management concerns (e.g., "fair market value") rather than the spiritual or moral treatment of devotees. There is no explicit section in the constitution or the underlying law that guarantees an individual devotee the right to be treated with justice by their superiors.

This systemic failure is compounded by the "phantom" nature of ISKCON’s judicial institutions. The Justice Ministry, according to internal critiques and GBC resolutions, has been "essentially defunct for many years" and has failed to establish a robust judicial process. Instead, the society relies on "ISKCONResolve," an ombudsman-style office that provides voluntary mediation. 

While mediation is useful for collaborative disputes, it is structurally incapable of delivering justice in cases of "official misconduct" or "abuse of power" because it lacks decision-making authority. A leader accused of wrongdoing can simply refuse to mediate, and the victim is left with no further recourse within the institutional framework.

Group in Power Hierarchy | Legal Protections | Disciplinary Exposure |

The Powerless (General Devotees) | Virtually none; no stated right to justice or compensation. | Subject to two full pages of "crimes and punishments" (censure, excommunication). |

The Officials (Temple Presidents) | Limited; right to appeal to GBC Zonal Secretary. | Subject to over two pages of rules for discipline and removal. |

The Lawmakers (GBC Members) | Substantial; disciplinary rules are opaque and often confidential. | No explicit GBC law detailing the process for disciplining a deviant member. |

The phenomenon of "enforcement inaction" is most pronounced in a culture of cronyism. When standards are "heaviest on the powerless... and most lenient with those who make the laws," the hierarchical nature of justice ensures that leaders are rarely held accountable for the same behaviors that would lead to the excommunication of a rank-and-file member. 

For example, while Temple Presidents are legally required to be "honest and trustworthy" and avoid "intimate dealings," there are no such explicit mandates for GBC members in the published law. This disparity creates a profound sense of disillusionment among the membership, who observe that "justice" is often a tool used by the hierarchy to maintain control rather than a principle used to protect the vulnerable.

Institutional Biases and the Marginalization of Dissent

The 2026 Constitution also institutionalizes biases against specific groups and viewpoints, often under the guise of "maintaining standards". One of the most significant biases is against internal dissenters, particularly the "ritvik" movement. Appendix 1 of the constitution explicitly rejects and bans "Ritvikism," labeling it as a deviation from the founder's instructions. 

While the GBC has the right to define its theology, using a constitutional document to permanently "ban" a competing interpretation of the founder’s mission functions as a form of "ecclesiastical silencing". This bias ensures that any devotee who holds a dissenting theological view is automatically categorized as an "offender," making them subject to the society’s disciplinary machinery.

There is also a latent bias regarding the status of women and cultural diversity. While recent resolutions mention "equal facility" for men and women, they often add the caveat "where culturally appropriate". The power to define what is "culturally appropriate" rests with the GBC, allowing them to pass "culturally sensitive resolutions" that can be modified for specific regions. 

While this appears flexible, it actually centralizes the definition of cultural norms; a Regional Governing Body (RGB) must apply to the GBC to adjust a resolution, meaning that local women's rights or social equity programs are entirely dependent on the approval of a global body that is predominantly male and traditionalist.

Axis of Bias | Mechanism of Marginalization | Institutional Impact |


Theological Dissent (Ritvik) | Explicit constitutional ban and categorization as "offense". | Excludes alternative interpretations of succession and initiation from the legal framework. |

Gender Equity | "Separate but equal" language paired with "cultural appropriateness" caveats. | Subordinates women's rights to regional "cultural norms" approved by the GBC. |

Local Autonomy | Rejection of the 1970 DOM electoral mandate. | Marginalizes the voice of the Temple Presidents and congregations in global governance. 

Member Rights | Omission of an enforceable Bill of Rights and independent judiciary. | Leaves the rank-and-file devotee without a legal shield against administrative abuse. 

The bias toward the GBC is not merely administrative; it is psychological. By framing the GBC as the "Foundational Instructing Spiritual Master" (śikṣā-guru) for the entire society, the constitution attempts to merge administrative authority with spiritual authority. This makes it difficult for "trusting followers" to distinguish between a managerial error and a spiritual directive. For a follower, questioning a GBC policy becomes equivalent to questioning one’s spiritual guide, a mentality that is highly conductive to the "culture of cronyism" where loyalty is prioritized over truth or justice.

Case Study in Governance Failure: The Bengaluru Litigation and its Implications
The long-standing dispute over the Hare Krishna Hill temple in Bengaluru provides a critical "real-world" test of the ISKCON Constitution’s legitimacy. For decades, ISKCON Mumbai (representing the GBC) and ISKCON Bengaluru (an independently registered society) have fought in the Indian court system over control of the temple and its vast resources. 

While the GBC’s constitution and laws claim that all ISKCON properties belong to a centralized authority, the Supreme Court of India has wrestled with the fact that many of these centers were founded with independent legal identities—a fact that aligns with Śrīla Prabhupāda’s "decentralized" instructions but contradicts the GBC’s "centralized" operational model.

The reopening of the case in 2026 by a three-judge bench of the Supreme Court underscores the "institutional authority and public trust" at stake. The court’s willingness to examine allegations of "forged or fabricated documents" used to establish ownership demonstrates that the secular legal system is often the only place where the GBC can be held to the standard of "fairness and finality". 

This litigation highlights the core flaw in the 2026 Constitution: because it provides no internal mechanism for independent arbitration, disputes between the center and the periphery inevitably escalate into costly, multi-decade secular lawsuits that damage the reputation of the entire movement. If the constitution had included the "checks and balances" and the "local autonomy" mandates of the 1970 DOM, such disputes could have been resolved through internal representative processes rather than in the public eye.

Synthesis: The Crisis of the 10,000-Year Plan

The 2026 ISKCON Constitution is presented as a document that will guide the movement for the next 10,000 years. However, without the basic structural features of modern constitutionalism—separation of powers, a Bill of Rights, and a representative electoral mandate—it remains a "machine bureaucracy" masquerading as a sacred charter. The inherent contradictions between its "love and trust" rhetoric and its "centralized control" reality create a high-friction environment for temple administrators and a dangerous environment for individual devotees.

The document is heavily biased toward the preservation of GBC power, shielding its members from the accountability that is demanded of their subordinates. By bypassing the 1970 "Direction of Management" and its requirement for elected, rotating leadership, the GBC has established a governance structure that is fundamentally at odds with the founder’s instructions to "discourage centralization". For the movement to achieve true institutional stability and spiritual vitality, its constitution must evolve from a manual of administrative control into a genuine charter of rights and representative governance. Without this evolution, the movement risks a future of increasing schism, legal entanglement, and the loss of the "love and trust" that was intended to be its true foundation

PADA: Well for starters, the ritviks are out, because we are: challenging the idea of offering bhogha to conditioned souls (which is why so many ISKCON folks are getting cancer?); we are making lawsuits to get original books -- and we are printing some originals; we are making lawsuits to address mass child mistreatment; and we are making new devotees of Srila Prabhupada. Yep, all that has to be stopped. ys pd 

WS: Iskcon will never make a comeback. 

RM: I only got to the part where it reckons ISKCON is a major global institution That says it all No one knows who ISKCON is That died long ago Hindus kinda know what ISKCON is and it's got a bad reputation from what I have seen 

GD: What an analysis! That was exhausting to read! And I can't imagine how exhausting the original document from the GBC! Jai ho! Govinda Dasi! Didn't Srila Prabhupada say our movement is based on love and trust? I think you said that in your well done analysis. I can't imagine how much time was spent on the production of that document that could have been spent on preaching, sankirtan. 

Wasn't S.P. original instructions for the GBC was to travel and preach to all the temples in their assigned zones, to encourage the devotees and maintain the standards of Bhakti are being followed? 

HH: I see more bureaucracy, more centralization, more going down the rabbit hole. GBC is trying to reinvent what Srila Prabhupada gave, making it crystal-clear and understandable for anyone. Though their reinvention makes the wheel an uncomfortable square. 

RM: I think Gemini established that their Constitution lacks any checks and balances and only serves to protect its Oligarchy members and to hell with individual members Did I get that right It's a hard read on a small phone screen.

GPD: Maybe better to stick to plan A given us by the founding acharia of iskcon Acbsp. Plan B hasn't worked in the last 50 years, how's plan C going to work if it deviates from the basic moral spiritual and other guidelines given by the iskcon acharia and the deciplic succession. 

GD#2 This post is a Gemini analysis of ISKCON’s new constitution. I searched for a copy or PDF of the actual constitution so we can judge the document for ourselves, but I could not find it, Does anyone have a link to the new constitution they can post here? 

PDD: While I appreciate it allllll being written and posted, can someone out there give a shortened version? 

TD: At the istaghosti they twice promoted it as a "living document" as though that were a plus. That just means it can change any time for anyone's convenience. That makes it sound like it deals with issues of the day rather than fixed principles you can always count on. 

KO: Kind of sounds like the hierarchy of the Roman Catholic Church

HA: Ship without a captain... ISKCON....? May be an image of sinking boat.

MA Dasi: There are many sincere bhaktas in the movement but not in the drivers seats. 

FSD: Chanting 16 rounds is the foundation...morning program 4 regs. prasadam.

AJD: Thanks for sharing. This analysis almost says it all as to how the GBC is trying sincerely but is seriously failing in many critical areas. For example, one iskcon guru was found guilty of child sex abuse by the ICPO and was banned. But the abusers buddies on the GBC overruled the conviction. This was clearly a very very serious abuse of power. 

RMD: I would like to see and share the actual GBC 2026 constitution. It is beyond any doubt that the great sinister movement has infiltrated ISKCON and those who follow Kali are doing their best to destroy it. Srila Gour Govinda Swami did say there are some real bhaktas in the society and that's why it still exists. 

I pray for protection of those souls and pray for the purification of ISKCON. Hare Krishna. 

GD#2: Those who follow Kali are doing their best to live off of it, it seems without having to perform any real seva !!! It seems ISKCON has become their private social security income!!! 

YMD: Eish, too long, wheres da essence ... I attend Sunday love feast n lecturer there don't utter anything about krsna, da lecture slowly traverses into money ....n how dedicated da Temple President is...idk why but..... 

BB: ISKCON has become a cold, impersonal business arrangement. They glorify the Hindus who give big donations and all the rest are not important. 

Sunday, February 8, 2026

Psychological Profile of Editor Defenders of the Bhagavad Gita Revision 02 08 26




PADA: Notice that all of these people are leaders in the "enforced cult ritualistic worship of homosexuals, pedophiles and deviants as messiahs for children program." A program which bans, beats, molests, sues and kills Vaishnavas. AKA the Mayapur "Auschwitz for kids" project. 

So now we also find out they are re-writing the Vedas to prop up their pooja for illicit sex with men, women and children messiah's club. Is anyone surprised? A victim of their program wrote to tell PADA, "for their making a program that is starving, beating and raping Vaishnava children, they will all be taking birth as bugs living in a dogs anus." Well yup, many people believe that is the case. 

I dunno, but I do know their future is very dark because their present is very dark already. How many people think the leaders of an Auschwitz for kids program are going to have a happy future? And on top of all that, they are changing all the books, which is another attack on the Vaishnava process. 

But hey, at least more people are waking up to what has been going on here. And history will record these people as the enemies of Vaishnava-ism, and they are already being recorded as such now. In other words, on top of their banning, beating, molesting, suing and killing Vaishnavas odious track record, we have to add -- re-writing the Vedas with conditioned soul speculation. But yeah, Jayadvaita says their messiahs are falling into illicit sex with men, women and maybe children, and that is why he is the hero writer of this group. Birds of a feather. 

ys pd angel108b@yahoo.com 

================= 

Psychological Profile of the Editors and Defenders of the Bhagavad Gita Revision.

The following observations are drawn exclusively from the arguments of Jayadvaita Swami and others throughout the 19 videos in this series. They are not clinical diagnoses but behavioral patterns that any attentive reader can verify.

1. Grandiosity Disguised as Humility

In Video 12, when Kesava Bharati Dasa (convicted by ISKCON itself as a child abuser) is asked which edition is closer to Prabhupada's intention, his answer is: he personally "hears Prabhupada's intention more clearly" in his own revision, and it "feels empowered and enlivened." This is not an editorial argument. It is a claim to privileged spiritual perception. 

He is saying, in effect, that he can perceive what Prabhupada truly meant better than Prabhupada's own published text communicates it. 

In Video 9, Gopiparanadhana Dasa goes further: "the second edition is more original than the first." The person who revised the book declares his revision more authentic than the author's own edition. This is grandiosity presented as devotional service.

2. Contempt for the Predecessor

The entire revision project is built on an unstated premise: that Hayagriva, Prabhupada's original editor, did a poor job. In Video 9, Gopiparanadhana Dasa describes Hayagriva as someone who "crossed out what he couldn't decipher." In Video 17, Hari Sauri Dasa explains the early editorial process as inadequate, with Prabhupada having to leave his work "in the hands of his disciples" because "he didn't have time" to review it. In Video 19, Jayadvaita Swami's contempt becomes explicit: "The Blessed Lord" is attributed directly to Hayagriva by name, as if identifying the source were sufficient to delegitimize the phrase. The implication is consistent: the original editorial work was deficient, and only the current editor can correct it. 

What is never acknowledged is that Prabhupada used the product of Hayagriva's work for five years without demanding a revision. Contempt for the predecessor is the emotional engine driving the project. For most of the series it remains implicit, but in Jayadvaita's Video 19 it surfaces openly: Hayagriva is named, blamed, and overruled.

3. Inversion of Accountability

A consistent pattern throughout the videos is the inversion of who must justify what. In Video 7, the editor offers to "change it back if evidence arises," as if the author-approved original text must now prove its validity against the revision. In Video 4, those who object to the changes are characterized as conspiracy theorists. In Video 14, defenders of the original text are called "fanatics." 

The person who altered 77% of a deceased author's book positions himself as the reasonable moderate, while those who say "don't change the author's published work" are the extremists. This inversion of accountability is psychologically revealing: it is the posture of someone who knows his position is difficult to defend and therefore must preemptively discredit those who question it.

4. Authority Without Limits

In Video 11, his argument is explicit: "editors by definition revise." Being appointed editor, in his view, constitutes blanket authorization for unlimited revision in perpetuity, even after the author's death. In Video 5, the argument extends further: since Prabhupada "never told them to stop editing," the editorial mandate is eternal. In Video 15, Prabhupada's acceptance of minor typographical corrections to the First Canto is extrapolated as authorization to revise 541 verses of the Bhagavad-gita. 

The pattern is one of progressive expansion: a narrow, specific authorization is stretched to cover unlimited scope. This is the behavior of someone who has assumed authority and then seeks justification retroactively, not of someone who received a clear mandate and is executing it.

5. Inability to Distinguish Himself from the Author

In Video 12, the editor states that his revision "feels empowered." In Video 9, he declares it "more original than the first." In Video 8, meaning-altering changes are defended as "restoration of Prabhupada's original intention." Throughout the entire series, there is no moment of doubt, no acknowledgment that the editor's perception of Prabhupada's intention might differ from Prabhupada's actual intention. Video 19 provides the most revealing formulation: "I felt justified in restoring it." Not "the evidence required it." Not "the manuscript demanded it." 

He felt justified. The basis for changing a sacred text is a personal feeling. The boundary between what the editor believes Prabhupada meant and what Prabhupada actually published has collapsed. This is psychological fusion: the editor has identified so completely with his role that he can no longer distinguish his own editorial preferences from the author's voice. When he changes a verse, he genuinely believes he is restoring Prabhupada. The possibility that he is substituting himself for Prabhupada does not seem to occur to him.

6. Minimization as a Defense Mechanism

In Video 1, the 5,000 changes are dismissed as "not impressive" because they include punctuation. In Video 4, Vaisesika Dasa says the change in BG 4.34 is "not particularly" problematic. In Video 7, the change from Visnu form/Visnu platform is "either way." Each individual change is presented as trivial when examined in isolation. But 541 verses is not trivial. The systematic minimization of individual changes serves to prevent the listener from perceiving the cumulative effect. This is a well-documented psychological defense mechanism: if each brick is insignificant, the wall they form somehow doesn't exist.

7. Deflection Through Emotional Framing

When faced with substantive criticism, the response throughout these videos is consistently emotional rather than evidentiary. In Video 8, the rhetorical question is "how dare you" -- directed not at the editor for changing the text, but at critics for objecting. In Video 14, critics are characterized as people who "shoot off in some direction" and are "totally unreasonable." In Video 5, engaging with textual evidence is dismissed as "nitpicking." The pattern is to deflect discussion from evidence (what was changed, why, and whether it matches the manuscript) toward emotion (loyalty, faith, empowerment, fanaticism). This is the behavior of someone who cannot win the evidentiary argument and therefore refuses to have it.

8. Vagueness Where Precision Is Needed

In Video 16, when asked about the authority for the revision, the answer is remarkably imprecise: "I could see a document where Srila Prabhupada said..." but what the document says is never specified. He describes having sent "some paper or documentation" and hedges: "I don't want to say manuscript." He recalls "a paper or letter or... whatever it was." For someone defending the most significant editorial intervention in the history of his tradition, the inability or unwillingness to cite specific documents with precision is revealing. Either the authorizing evidence does not exist in the form claimed, or the editor has not felt the need to verify it carefully, because the decision was made on other grounds and the documentation is invoked as post-hoc justification.

9. The Psychology of the Fait Accompli

Perhaps the most important observation is structural rather than specific to any individual video. The revision was completed and published decades ago. Every argument in this series is a defense of a fait accompli, not a proposal for future action. This fundamentally shapes the psychology: the editor is not asking permission. He is explaining why what he already did was right. 

This creates a psychological imperative to justify at all costs, because admitting that the revision was unauthorized or unfaithful would require confronting decades of invested identity. The arguments do not need to be logically rigorous because their function is not to persuade through logic. Their function is to provide sufficient rhetorical cover for the editor and his followers to continue believing in the legitimacy of what has already been done.

10. Theological Imprecision Disguised as Academic Rigor

In Video 19, Jayadvaita criticizes Gita Press for using impersonal terms like "Paramatma" and "Parabrahma" and places "Blessed Lord" in the same category. This conflation is theologically illiterate. "Blessed Lord" is a devotional and personal term -- it conveys adoration, sovereignty, and grace. It is the opposite of the impersonal "Parabrahma." The inability or unwillingness to distinguish between a reverential personal address and an impersonal philosophical abstraction suggests that the editor's objection to "Blessed Lord" is not theological at all. It is territorial: Hayagriva chose the phrase, therefore it must go. The theological argument is constructed afterward to rationalize what is fundamentally an act of displacement.

Summary

What emerges from these 19 videos is not the portrait of careful scholars defending their work with evidence. It is the portrait of people who made a consequential decision decades ago, identified their entire spiritual identity with that decision, and now experience any challenge to the revision as a challenge to their own legitimacy. The arguments are not built from evidence toward a conclusion. They begin with the conclusion -- that the revision was correct -- and work backward to find justifications. 

This explains why the arguments are inconsistent (the original is both deficient enough to require a complete overhaul and sacred enough to invoke Prabhupada's authority), why critics are dismissed rather than engaged, and why subjective impressions of "empowerment" are offered as evidence alongside procedural claims about institutional authority. These are not the arguments of someone seeking truth. They are the arguments of someone defending a position that has become inseparable from their sense of self.

Videos Cited (with link to the exact moment)

Video 1 — "Why 5,000 changes?"
• "The number doesn't impress me" — https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jBQoYoridyU&t=79

Video 4 — "Do you have a problem with the change in BG 4.34?"
• "Not particularly... unless one thinks there's a conspiracy" — https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y-dt0Pv8eR4&t=18

Video 5 — "Is it appropriate to edit Prabhupada's books after his departure?"
• "I'm convinced that certain disciples are empowered to edit his books" — https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8kupWFJuyvQ&t=172

• "He never told them to stop editing" — https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8kupWFJuyvQ&t=184

• "Better than nitpicking about what's original" — https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8kupWFJuyvQ&t=302

Video 7 — "Why did you change 'Visnu form' to 'Visnu platform'?"

• "It's not sacred, it's not that serious" — https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9m76vZd1rGA&t=43

• "What kind of principle is that?" — https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9m76vZd1rGA&t=94

Video 8 — "Why do some changes seriously alter the meaning?"

• "Is that terrible? Is it sinful?" — https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3lp8t5AG1vA&t=42

• "How dare you?" — https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3lp8t5AG1vA&t=48

Video 9 — "Why edit a book already edited and approved?"

• Hayagriva "simply crossed it out with a black marker" — https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7Px-W57nt4Y&t=53

• "The original is what comes from Prabhupada's mouth, not what was published" — https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7Px-W57nt4Y&t=123

• "The second edition is more original than the first" — https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7Px-W57nt4Y&t=143

Video 11 — "Prabhupada opposed changes. Why change?"

• "For practically ten years my prescribed duty was to change" — https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OX2X_o3OzGg&t=41

• "Editors are people who by definition revise" — https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OX2X_o3OzGg&t=62

• "Somehow Prabhupada trusted me" — https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OX2X_o3OzGg&t=95

Video 12 — "Which edition do you consider closer to Prabhupada's intention?"

• "What I see is Prabhupada's intention more clearly" — https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ff9PZ4cA7oM&t=17

• "I hear his intention and that gives me faith... it's empowered" — https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ff9PZ4cA7oM&t=37

• "The second edition is empowered" — https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ff9PZ4cA7oM&t=51

Video 13 — "Why did you add to the purport of BG 4.34?"

• "It's not my fault, that's what Prabhupada said" — https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=I8x2qtx_6t4&t=19

• "It's common sense" — https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=I8x2qtx_6t4&t=44

Video 14 — "Shouldn't we simply be faithful and loyal to Prabhupada?"

• "Devotees become fanatics about preserving errors" — https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RlPqHhmitTo&t=34

• "They make a big mistake themselves" — https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RlPqHhmitTo&t=76

• "They shoot off in some direction... it's totally unreasonable" — https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RlPqHhmitTo&t=92

Video 15 — "Does the BBT have authority for posthumous corrections?"

• "The authority comes from Prabhupada's desire that his books be free of errors" — https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=l3AAi9LxjJQ&t=17

• "Prabhupada accepted them without seeing them" — https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=l3AAi9LxjJQ&t=62

• "The idea that the books were frozen is fallacious" — https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=l3AAi9LxjJQ&t=108

Video 16 — "By what authority did Jayadvaita Swami re-edit the Gita?"

• "I could see a document where Srila Prabhupada said..." — https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lrqpR_tF6ns&t=18

• "Whatever it was, a paper or letter or... I don't want to say manuscript" — https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lrqpR_tF6ns&t=54

Video 17 — "Did Prabhupada approve all the editing?"

• "Even the best writers need a good editor, Srila Prabhupada included" — https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uQiA_70ny5I&t=25

• "He didn't look at it again... he didn't have time" — https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uQiA_70ny5I&t=70

• "He knew there were going to be some mistakes" — https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uQiA_70ny5I&t=98

Video 19 — "Why did you change 'The Blessed Lord said'?"
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rpV54tfQ_O8

Spanish version: 

=====


TWD: While every issue of corruption in our movement is important and forms part of a greater tapestry regarding the overall hijacking of the mission, the book change issue is arguably more important than any other. Sure, they murdered Srila Prabhupada's vapu form through homicidal poisoning, but the book changes are even worse, because the agents of Kali are now killing the Acharya's vani form, through which he continues to live and to deliver us from ignorance. The ritualistic child abuse syndicate within ISKCON is symptomatic of the demonic nature of those who hijacked the movement. Part of that is to traumatise the younger generation and drive them away. The guru issue is also important, as well several murders of outspoken devotees over the years, and many other issues as well.
But the book issue trumps all other issues, because once the original books are gone, they are gone. And Mr. Jay Israel of the BBT(I) has made it clear that they intend for that to happen. So we must save the original editions of Srila Prabhupada's books while we still can. It's nice that devotees are starting to realise that Srila Prabhupada is our primary link and is the initiating diksha guru of the society he founded, but even that transmission of diksha which takes place regardless of whether or not the ceremony has been performed, depends on maintaining the authenticity of his recorded vani, which the demons are trying to erase.

Saturday, February 7, 2026

More 1975 Troubles / Kirtan Video / Srila Saraswati / ISKCON Constitution 02 17 26






===

Drums back in stock! 


==


ISKCON CONSTITUTION

Anon Dasa: UNDER ISKCON'S NEW CONSTITUTIONAL DOCUMENT, I AM NOT CONSIDERED TO BE ABLE TO BE A MEMBER OF ISKCON IN GOOD STANDING...

So I downloaded the GBC's (Gangster Boys Club) new ISKCON constitution in PDF format. The first thing I did was ctrl + F and searched for the word "ritvik" to see what I already knew would come up - which is as follows:

A.6. RITVIKISM: REJECTED AND BANNED

A.6.1. The theory that Śrīla Prabhupāda wished to continue directly initiating disciples after his departure through “ritviks ” – celebrants performing the ceremony of initiation on his behalf – is a philosophical deviation that goes against the paramparā principle established by Lord Krishna and upheld by all our ācāryas. Ritvikism is never mentioned in śāstra, has never been practiced by any bonafide sampradāya, and Śrīla Prabhupāda never presented or endorsed it.

A.6.2. The ritvikism falsehood shall be permanently shunned in ISKCON as unfounded and misleading. It is utterly erroneous to espouse it, deluding and misguiding to teach it, and blasphemous to attribute it to Śrīla Prabhupāda.

A.6.3. The ritvikism invention shall be banned in ISKCON; it shall not be tolerated or accommodated in any way, shape, or form. No one who espouses, teaches, or practices ritvikism can be an ISKCON member in good standing.

PADA: That is quite a relief. We were worried the GBC would allow us into ISKCON. We should not be associated with the odious karma of the GBC's worship of illicit sex with men, women and children guru program. We should also not eat anything offered to that sampradaya. We do not want anyone to be a supportive part of their program, so let our people be out of theirs, and be independent. 

This is really an advertisement for everyone to leave that corrupt program. And we are. Yep, there is no "parampara from Krishna" that worships ACTUAL pure devotees, there is only a parampara that contains -- homosexuals, pedophiles, drunks, drug addicts, porno addicts, and people who are falling down left, right and center. And just before they leave and bloop, they "2/3 show of hands" vote in more "parampara members." Told ya!  

ys pd

angel108b@yahoo.com   

=================

#390

DATE: 4 February 2025

Re: ISKCON’S SHUDRA GBCs

Dear Friends and Members, Dandavats to all genuine followers of Shrila Prabhupada. Take a look around today’s ISKCON and you’ll see rampant shudra values in every corner of the brick-and-mortar church that ISKCON has morphed into. And that’s because the leadership has deteriorated into shudra quality. Shudra values are seen everywhere. Prabhupada warned:

“Therefore we have created these GBC. So they should be very responsible men. Otherwise, they will be punished. They will be punished to become a shudra.
Although Yamaraja is a GBC, but he made a little mistake. He was punished to become a shudra. So those who are GBC’s, they should be very, very careful to administer the business of ISKCON. Otherwise they will be punished. As the post is very great, similarly, the punishment is also very great.” (Srila Prabhupada Lecture, June 4th, 1974)

And now the inevitable has happened because the GBC shudras did not listen. The fingerprints of ISKCON’s shudra GBCs are everywhere. Just see…

-ISKCON Swamis crowd surfing and doing shudra dances before the Deities just to please the crowds of their blind, admiring shudra fans.

-ISKCON Swamis living luxuriously like “extravagant shudras” on money provided by the struggling working class “disciples” that they exploit.

-Several ISKCON Swamis and GBCs live like millionaire playboys with their female attendants and masseuses.

-Bogus news propaganda is rampant on ISKCON’s shudra disinformation network ISKCON News.

-Affection for shudra class Mayavadi swamis is seen in ISKCON shameful publication The Journey Home and other books written by ISKCON shudra “leaders.”

-The shudra-quality “acharya” of The Journey Home has been named by witnesses as the one who gave the order for murdering Sulochan.

-Physical gymnastic yoga exercises are taught to shudras for money at many 
ISKCON centers.

-ISKCON preachers have turned into paid shudra “life coaches.”

-ISKCON shudra Swami Radhanath has started a trend of shudra worship by installing a deity of himself in Prabhupada’s temple.

- Some ISKCON shudra “acharyas” and “gurus” have been exposed as dangerous predators and sometimes even pedophiles in ISKCON, or they supported a system that created these problems.

-Smart-ass shudra know-it-alls in the BBT have radically changed Prabhupada’s books because they have listed Prabhupada as their “worker for hire.”

-The shudra GBC and shudra Swamis accept grand luxurious feasts while Gurukula children have been starved.

-Bhaktivedanta degrees handed out by unqualified shudras to other shudras at Mayapur.

-Cheap sahajiyaism, shudra imitation devotion, is rampant as seen in the books of GBC Shivaram, who runs ISKCON News, the shudra propaganda service.

-”Devotee care” is just a sham to cover up all the abuse that has been meted out by shudra leaders to honest devotees who have spoken up over the years.

-The greatest influence ISKCON is having nowadays is seen in films that expose ISKCON’s shudra corrupt practices. Movies like MONKEY ON A STICK, Peacock’s TV special KRISHNAS:GURUS, KARMA, MURDER, and Wonderly’s online expose are showing the public what ISKCON today is made of. 

Rather than honoring the pioneering spiritual activities of the Founder- Acharya Shrila Prabhupada, ISKCON’s shudra leaders have sent the Hare Krishna Movement into mission drift.

-No one in the media listens to ISKCON’s GBC shudra apologist Anuttama das.

-The video about shudra GBC Emeritus Giriraja Swami’s lurid and vulgar sexual affair with a much younger disciple has been widely viewed on Hare Krishna Podcast.

-When huge sums of money “go missing” in ISKCON, the shudra GBC simply scrambles to cover up the scandal.

-ISKCON attends interfaith ceremonies with other shudra religious groups to show agreement with “other religions.”

-ISKCON’s official policy is that it is a Hindu organization in many areas, simply to attract the wealth of Indian shudra professionals.

-Blooped gurus living like kings in devotee communities like Harikesh, supposedly with money handed over by fellow shudra GBCs and swamis.

-It is evident that there is a shudra cabal, an inner circle in ISKCON, that has directed the movement back into the realm of the lower classes. Prabhupada predicts the future GBC destruction of ISKCON

“What will happen when I am not here, shall everything be spoiled by GBC? So for the time being, let the GBC activities be suspended until I thoroughly revise the whole procedure.” (Srila Prabhupada Letter, April 11th, 1972)

“I made the GBC to give me relief, but if you do like this, then where is the relief. It is anxiety for me. This is the difficulty, that as soon as one gets power, he becomes whimsical and spoils everything.” (Srila Prabhupada Letter, September 12th, 1974 )

“I am training some of my experienced disciples how to manage after my departure. So if instead of taking the training, if in my lifetime you people say I am the Lord of all I survey, that is dangerous conspiracy.” (Srila Prabhupada Letter, October 8th, 1974)

Prabhus, don’t follow shudras. Prabhupada wanted his ISKCON to be a movement of Vaishnava brahmanas, so we must strive for that standard rather than compromising with the trade-offs of a milquetoast sell-out.

The goal is great, so do it.

Yours always in the service of the Vaishnavas,

Your A.I.S.F. Team

=================

"IT IS A FACT HOWEVER THAT THE GREAT SINISTER MOVEMENT IS WITHIN OUR SOCIETY" ~ Srila Prabhupada
 
(Excerpt from Srila Prabhupada's letter to Hansadutta, 2nd September 1970)

"Regarding the poisonous effect in our Society, it is a fact and I know where from this poison tree has sprung up and how it affected practically the whole Society in a very dangerous form. But it does not matter. Prahlada Maharaj was administered poison, but it did not act. Similarly Lord Krsna and the Pandavas were administered poison and it did not act. I think in the same parampara system that the poison administered to our Society will not act if some of our students are as good as Prahlad Maharaj. I have therefore given the administrative power to the Governing Body Commission.

"I have tried to give you all Krsna Consciousness, now it is your duty to develop it. If you remain strong on the spiritual platform then your progress will not be checked or blocked. I do not know what was resolved in New Vrndavana although Sriman Rupanuga Prabhu has informed others that he has sent a tape in this connection. I am still in darkness about the proceedings in New Vrndavana, but I have heard that Brahmananda is preaching about me that I am Krsna, that I am Supersoul, that I have withdrawn my mercy from the disciples, that I have left the Society and so on. 

"I do not know how far they are correct, but I have written him a letter that he may not do something which may harm the interest of the Society. You are also one of the members of the GBC, so you can think over very deeply how to save the situation. It is a fact however that the great sinister movement is within our Society. I have not heard anything from Krsna das or Shyamsundar, so all of you may try to save the Society from this dangerous position.

Read More:


=====

BOMBING THE DOGS

PADA: Wow pilgrims, Russia has discovered another national security issue that has to be taken down before it attacks Russia! It is the DANGEROUS animals! There are many reports of Russia bombing animal farms, killing probably hundreds of thousands, if not millions -- of cows, chickens, sheep and other farm animals. 

I have seen photos of cow barns that were obliterated, obviously on purpose -- to kill the cows. And there were hundreds of cows laying around, this was intentional. Russia obviously believes cows, dangerously chewing their cud in a field, are a security threat to their nation! Kill them before they kill us! 

Well now Russia has found yet another dangerous national security problem, it is not only old granny ladies who are sewing sweaters for their kittens in hi-rise buildings, now the big enemy is -- animal shelters! 

We must kill these dogs in the shelter before they kill off Russia's army and invade Moscow! These Russian guys are so paranoid, they think an animal shelter is a danger to their national security. OK they probably know animals are not really a threat, they just take great delight in killing anything that moves. ys pd        




Thursday, February 5, 2026

More Patna Discussion / ISKCON and Women / Aryan Women 02 15 26


You can get English sound if you click on the CC

PADA: This is my recent AI art of Radha and Krishna, made on the Gemini Google platform. I am pretty happy with it, and I went in and touched up some areas on I-pad Procreate. Jayate. ys pd

1) O Gopinatha, Lord of the gopis, please hear my request. I am a wicked materialist, always addicted to worldly desires, and no good qualities do I possess.

2) O Gopinatha, You are my only hope, and therefore I have taken shelter at Your lotus feet. I am now Your eternal servant.

3) O Gopinatha, how will You purify me? I do not know what devotion is, and my materialistic mind is absorbed in fruitive work. I have fallen into this dark and perilous worldly existence.

4) O Gopinatha, everything here is Your illusory energy. I have no strength or transcendental knowledge, and this body of mine is not independent and free from the control of material nature.

5) O Gopinatha, this sinner, who is weeping and weeping, begs for an eternal place at Your divine feet. Please give him Your mercy.

6) O Gopinatha, You are able to do anything, and therefore You have the power to deliver all sinners. Who is there that is more of a sinner than myself?

7) O Gopinatha, You are the ocean of mercy. Having come into this phenomenal world, You expand Your divine pastimes for the sake of the fallen souls.

8) O Gopinatha, I am so sinful that although all the demons attained Your lotus feet, Bhaktivinoda has remained in worldly existence.

=================

Krishna Sanctuary

Seems to be a nice project. 

======

ISKCON and WOMEN

PADA: Henry Doktosrski sent me an article on how women in general were viewed very negatively at New Vrndavana. And as a result many women were exploited and abused. He blames Srila Prabhupada for creating this environment. Except, my view is that New Vrndavana folks were getting the "Kirtanananda's filtered" view of women, and Krishna consciousness, and Kirtanananda was cherry picking certain negative quotes, while avoiding positive quotes, to suppress women -- and to suppress those quotes. 

And his program suppressed those of us citing these positive quotes, and the quotes exposing Kirtanananda, to the point their empire would have us assassinated for publishing and citing these quotes -- that opposed their views, being afraid of being exposed. 

For example when people at New Vrndavana said "Srila Prabhupada says Kirtanananda is a pure devotee." OK he might have said that once. Yet he also said: KS is a crazy man -- who needs to go back to Bellvue; KS indulges in a strange form of sense gratification (homosexuality); KS stole my Gita manuscript -- and so forth. 

Srila Prabhupada also said Jayatirtha is my tirtha, and his followers slammed that in my face all day long. But he was falling down. Just because Srila Prabhupada makes a few encouraging statements about someone, that is not an absolute endorsement.  

When someone who is elderly is encouraging a kindergarten child, they may say things that are not meant to be absolute. When we tell a toddler -- you are doing a great job bringing me my shoe, that does not mean the child knows how to fetch the other shoe and etc. It is encouraging, but not making an absolute statement of fact.   

I had a gay friend in San Francisco who told me, unfortunately there are homosexuals who see women negatively, as competition, and they treat women rudely and badly. They want to keep women in a lower status, to cut down their competitors, so the homosexual program is enhanced. In short they are ENVIOUS of women, or even worse -- they hate women.

And that is evidently why Kirtanananda called his istagosthi meetings with women "fish night," and Devamrta said women are like toilets, and the list of negative comments from these (homosexual ilk) leader guys from New Vrndavana are endless really. OK these guys were many times homosexuals -- who did not like women -- and they created an anti-women atmosphere.

I personally never understood that we should exploit, suppress or oppress women from the teachings of Krishna. Rather, women are supposed to be my spiritual "soul sisters" --  aka eternal spirit souls -- fully equal to myself -- who are now in a female shaped, temporary material covering or body. And it is our duty to see them as spiritual soul equals, parts and parcels of God, and not as our inferiors. 

One thing many people probably do not know is that most of the help I got at the start of PADA was from -- women -- who were acting as my spies and agents to get my news stories for PADA. And a woman was the first person I helped to sue ISKCON for child abuse, in 1986. Women were somewhat at the forefront of helping me challenging the homosexual and pedophile messiah's program, and subsequently today mostly women are on the ISKCON Vedic Inquiry child welfare forum etc. now. 

OK women did a lot to challenge the GBC, and they still are, more than many or most men. Srila Prabhupada also told us that women are the backbone of religion in India, since 90% of the people at our Pandal festivals were -- women. He encouraged those ladies, and therefore wanted us to do the same. 

In sum, the lady I helped with the 1986 lawsuit was more brave than all the ISKCON men put together, because it was somewhat dangerous to challenge the GBC regime at that time. Many of the men simply did not help, or worse, said I was making offenses to the seniors etc. So my view was always that women can be a good source of inspiration and help, and they have been. 

Instead of suppressing women, I was always encouraging them, and that was my understanding of the Krishna philosophy, women should be treated with maturity and respect. Or as Srila Prabhupada says, treat all women as mother. 

New Vrndavana was a sort of really bad place for women, because these leaders -- who are envious of women -- began to artificially make women an inferior class of person -- and then there was a lot of sexual and physical abuse of women as a result. But I never liked these leaders, nor did I like the way women were being made into lesser class beings by some of these leaders, when the women should be seen as equals and moreover respected as "living temples of Vishnu" and Krishna's parts and parcels etc. 

But I am a guy who is kind to my neighborhood squirrels and birds, and I feed them every day. I have no tolerance for mistreating any living being, it is not the correct idea of the Krishna religion. All living beings should be seen as temples of Vishnu, especially the Vaishnavi ladies who are worshiping Vishnu.   

What Srila Prabhupada also said was, every woman should be protected and hopefully married. And he suspended sannyasa saying the leaders should be grhasthas or married people. He said women should be honored and protected, thus he never authorized exploiting them, never mind mistreating them, beating them, and so forth. Nor did I ever feel that mistreating or exploiting women is what the Krishna society is supposed to be doing.  

In any case all religions have some form of ashram type program to try to keep the men monks or brahmacaris separated from the women. And the women try to avoid the men by living as nuns or brahmacarinis. In Muslim countries the ladies cover their faces and so on. That is because Srila Prabhupada is correct, men mixing with ladies can turn into lusty affairs. That is common in all religions.   

In New Vrndavana, in the name of avoiding lust, practice of austerity and renunciation, some men were having illicit affairs with a number of women. Some women were given coercive divorces and were married off to other men. Some women told me they were never officially married, there was simply a "garland exchange," and not a legal recorded marriage, and thus they were un-officially married and maybe re-married later with no documentation. That gave them no legal footing for child custody, spousal benefits etc. 

Much worse, adult homosexual men were having various forms of sex with men and boys who were still minors. And some of the females there told me they were being married off when they were not yet 18. OK so there was a lot of lusty stuff going on left, right and center, including heterosexual, homosexual and even pedophile lusty affairs, or in sum -- illicit sex with men, women and children. Sorry, this is not a place that is "following Krishna." 

That means Srila Prabhupada is correct -- lust is the main enemy of spiritual practitioners. So if someone thinks New Vrndavana is an example of Srila Prabhupada's teachings, they are severely misguided. Srila Prabhupada says illicit behavior takes a person to hell, and that behavior was rampant at New Vrndavana in all forms. 

When CBS news Jane Wallace visited new Vrndavana, she was mortified to see Kirtanananda sitting on a big seat, covered with the hands of young boys. Worse, some of the big leaders were in the audience there singing "Jaya Bhaktipada." She asked me if this is pedophile heaven, I said yep it is. And she said thank God we met at least one Hare Krishna who knows this is pedophile heaven. OK all these ISKCON men could not see the problem there, but she -- a so called karmi woman -- could see.

She also said many of the ladies there have "children who look different, as if the children came from different fathers." She asked me if the ladies there "are being passed around to various men." And I said -- probably yes. OK so a woman news reporter, who has no knowledge of the Vedas, immediately -- withing a few seconds -- understands that New Vrndavana is a pedophile cult, while the "men" there were all chanting "Jaya Bhaktipada," which alarmed CBS news folks. 

Sorry, these New Vrndavana folks are not following Srila Prabhupada, or even basic common moral religion principles. Worship of homosexuals and pedophiles as messiahs is not done even in the mleccha society. And when we had New Vrndavana sued on the $400,000,000 case, the lawyers said New Vrndavana is the worst place for children abuse in the whole USA ISKCON.   

When Ravindra Swarupa wanted to remove Kirtanananda, 300 families (many Prabhupada original disciples) made a petition to keep KS as the guru there. OK so this was a homosexual and pedophile personality cult, which has nothing to do with Srila Prabhupada. Unfortunately, it fooled a lot of people into thinking it is bona fide. It never was. 

Sulochana said Chakradhari was murdered because he protested at an istagosthi that Kirtanananda was having affairs with boys. I would say many -- if not most -- people there knew something bad was afoot. 

Yeah I would say, a lot of people there must have known about all these illicit, illegal and exploiting things going on there, if they were not participating in the crimes themselves. It is just impossible for me to believe all the banning, beating, molesting, lawsuits, and murders were not known by a lot of people, if not most people. 

In any case, we never believed that Kirtanananda was purely representing Krishna -- ever. I never really liked the guy, and we knew him, Hayagriva, Umapati and others were from the Mott Street boys program, and we suspected they were not solid followers the whole time. Nor did we ever think a Mott Stret boy could be catapulted to being a pure devotee in the space of 10 years, especially when these guys were chastised so badly right out of the gate. 

Anyway, for those who thought the GBC's program was Prabhupada's program, you folks made a huge mistake. He was apparently poisoned by that sabha to get him out of the way. And what happened next was not his desire, order, mission or movement. 

Jane Wallace was able to figure out in two seconds what a lot of these people could not figure out in two decades, and many of them still cannot. This was a not a religious movement, it was "pedophile heaven." She thanked me for being the one of the only Hare Krishnas who knew what was what, because almost all the other devotees defended the program. Kirtanananda was later buried in a samadhi, because a lot of people still don't get it. 

OK they got suckered. 

ys pd angel108b@yahoo.com  

HOW TO VIEW WOMEN (or any living entity):

BG 13.3 I AM THE KNOWER WITHIN ALL BODIES

kṣetra-jñaḿ cāpi māḿ viddhi
sarva-kṣetreṣu bhārata
kṣetra-kṣetrajñayor jñānaḿ
yat taj jñānaḿ mataḿ mama

Translation of Bhagavad Gita 13.3

O scion of Bharata, you should understand that I am also the knower in all bodies, and to understand this body and its knower is called knowledge. That is My opinion.

Commentary by Sri A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupada of Gaudiya Sampradaya:

While discussing the subject of the body and the knower of the body, the soul and the Supersoul, we shall find three different topics of study: the Lord, the living entity, and matter. In every field of activities, in every body, there are two souls: the individual soul and the Supersoul. Because the Supersoul is the plenary expansion of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Krishna, Krishna says, “I am also the knower, but I am not the individual knower of the body. 

I am the superknower. I am present in every body as the Paramatma, or Supersoul.” One who studies the subject matter of the field of activity and the knower of the field very minutely, in terms of this Bhagavad-gita, can attain to knowledge.

The Lord says, “I am the knower of the field of activities in every individual body.” The individual may be the knower of his own body, but he is not in knowledge of other bodies. The Supreme Personality of Godhead, who is present as the Supersoul in all bodies, knows everything about all bodies. He knows all the different bodies of all the various species of life. A citizen may know everything about his patch of land, but the king knows not only his palace but all the properties possessed by the individual citizens. Similarly, one may be the proprietor of the body individually, but the Supreme Lord is the proprietor of all bodies. The king is the original proprietor of the kingdom, and the citizen is the secondary proprietor. Similarly, the Supreme Lord is the supreme proprietor of all bodies.

=================

This article, ‘The Vaiṣṇavism of Ancient Āryan Women,’ was first published in Sajjana Toṣaṇī, Volume 2, Issue 9, in 1885. In it, Bhaktivinoda Ṭhākura narrates the account of Śaṅkarācārya’s mother, who, as she lay on her deathbed, expressed her longing to attain Vaikuṇṭha.

by Śrīla Bhaktivinoda Ṭhākura

(This article has been compiled from the Śaṅkara Vijaya composed by Sāyanācārya).

Nowadays, who would not feel delighted when the subject of the steadfast devotion of Indian women is discussed? We shall not now speak about the two maidservant daughters Pil and Pilyā described in the Bhaktamāla, nor about other noble women, because the time for that has not yet come for us. The devout lady of whom we shall now inform the learned and respectable readers may be said to be well known even among the mature educated class of men.

Eleven centuries ago, in the village of Kālapi in the land of Kerala, there lived a brāhmaṇa by the name of Śivaguru Śarmā. He was the father of Śaṅkarācārya, the crest-jewel of parivrājakācāryas, and his wife was the mother of that best of ācāryas, Śaṅkara Svāmī. Śaṅkara’s mother gave birth to that world-renowned Śaṅkarācārya on the day of Śukla Ekādaśī in the month of Vaiśākha in the 71st year of the Śaka era.*

niṣe nāgebha bahnyabde vibhave māsi mādhave

śukle tithau daśamyāstu śaṅkarāryodayaḥ smṛtaḥ

ārya vidyā sudhākara dhṛta tat sampradāyikṛta śloka

“In the year 3889 of the Kali Era (778 CE), in the month of Mādhava, on the bright tenth lunar day, the birth of Śaṅkara is remembered. This śloka, upholding the nectar of āryan learning, is composed according to the sampradāyika tradition.”

Later, after Śaṅkara had embraced the order of sannyāsa and, while travelling through many lands, was residing on the mountain called Śṛṅga, surrounded by his own disciples such as Sureśācārya and engaged in discussion of the Vedānta śāstra, at that time the final hour of his mother approached. At that time, the mother of the venerable world-teacher – due to advanced age and the frailty of widowhood – was exceedingly weak. 

Seeing that her own end was near, she began repeatedly recalling her only son who was a sannyāsi. Śaṅkara, being omniscient, was able to hear the anguished cries of his mother even while residing on the Śṛṅga mountain. Then, leaving his disciples, by the power of his yogika strength, he immediately proceeded to the village of Kālapi and paid respects at his mother’s feet. The wife of Śivaguru, seeing her child before her as if in a dream, became exceedingly joyful and began to say, ‘Son, my final moment has now arrived. I am an ignorant and helpless woman. Please tell me what duty I should now perform.”

Hearing his mother’s words of distress, Śaṅkara began to instruct her about the non-differentiated Brahman that he had previously expounded. But his mother, showing her inability to grasp that, replied, “Son! I am a woman – I have no capacity to contemplate that non-differentiated Brahman. Therefore, please teach me about a beautiful, tangible form of Brahman.”

Then Śaṅkara instructed his mother to contemplate the nature of all beings and the essence of Bhūtanātha (Śiva). He began to recite in the bhujaṅga-prayāta metre a hymn in praise of the eight forms of Mahādeva. Pleased with that hymn, Śiva, wielding the trident and Pīṇaka bow, sent his attendants to honour her. Seeing this, Śaṅkara’s mother became dissatisfied and said, “I will not go along with the attendants of Śiva.”*

*vilokyatān śula pināka hastam

naivānugaccheyamitibruvastyām

Having seen them, with trident and Pināka in hand, she said, ‘I will not follow.’ (Śaṅkara Vijaya)

Then the crest-jewel of parivrājakācāryas, perceiving that no other recourse remained, understood his mother’s unparalleled bhakti to Śrī Kṛṣṇa. Overjoyed, he began to recite verses in praise of the supremely merciful Lord of Lakṣmī, who is most affectionate to His devotees.

For the benefit of the readers, three ślokas gathered by Sāyanīya Mādhavācārya are quoted here:

bhujagādhipa bhogatalpa bhājaṁ

kamalākṣa sthala kalpitāṅghri padmaṁ

abhivījitamādareṇa līlā-

vasudhābhyāṁ calamāna cāmarābhyāṁ


vihitāñjalinā niṣevyamāṇaṁ

vinatānanda kṛtāgrato rathena

dhṛta-mūrtibhirastra devatābhiḥ

paritaṁ pañcabhirañcitopakaṇṭaṁ


mahanīya-tamāla-komalaṅgaṁ

mukuṭī-ratna-cayaṁ mahār’yantaṁ

śiśiretara-bhānu-śīlitāgraṁ

hari-nīlopala-bhūdharaṁ hasantaṁ

(Vishnu) He who uses the coils of the serpent-king as a couch; whose lotus-feet are placed upon the bosom of Lakṣmī; who is gently fanned with affection by Līlā and Vasudhā, with cāmaras moving to and fro; He who is attended with folded palms by the joyful son of Vinatā (Garuḍa), who acts as His chariot; who is surrounded by His five weapons (the conch, discus, club, bow and sword) who have assumed personified celestial forms; whose limbs are tender like the revered tamāla tree; who is adorned with clusters of jewels set upon His crown; whose face is radiant like the sun; who playfully outshines the sapphire with the beauty of His body – I praise that smiling Hari, the supporter of the earth, who is blue, like a sapphire.

Śivaguru’s wife, hearing this regal prayer to the Supreme Deity, Śrī Kṛṣṇa composed by her own son as his own means, became exceedingly joyful; and while contemplating the enchanting form of Śrī Śrī Mādhava, she abandoned her body like a yogī. At that moment, Viṣṇu swiftly arrived, accompanied by a celestial aerial car radiant like the autumnal moon. Seating Śaṅkara’s mother upon that Vaiṣṇava vimāna, He carried her beyond the realms of the Sun, the Moon, Varuṇa, Indra, and even Brahmaloka, and brought her to the supreme abode of Lord Viṣṇu, in other words, Vaikuṇṭha-dhāma.

(‘The Vaiṣṇavism of Ancient Āryan Women,’ was first published in Sajjana Toṣaṇī, Volume 2, Issue 9, in 1885 and translated by Swami Bhaktivijñāna Giri)